Reigate Priory become one of the 16 founder members of the Surrey Cricketers League who compete as a league for the first time in 1971. The finishing positions for the club are detailed below.

1971 - 16th
1972 - 14th
1973 - 10th
1974 - 14th
1975 - 12th
1976 - 15th
1977 - 8th
1978 - 7th
1979 - 3rd Extended to 17 clubs
1980 - 10th Extended to 18 clubs
1981 - 8th
1982 - 10th
1983 - 3rd
1984 - 10th
1985 - 7th
1986 - 6th
1987 - 11th The league becomes the 2nd Div. of Surrey Championship
1988 - 2nd Promoted to 22 club 1st Division of Surrey Championship
1989 - 15th 1st Division
1990 - 4th
1991 - 4th
1992 - 15th
1993 - 10th
1994 - 21st Relegated to 2nd Division
1995 - 1st Straight back up as Champions
1996 - 4th
1997 - 7th
1998 - 12th Top 10 clubs form Premier Division. Miss cut
1999 - 2nd Promoted to Premier Division from 1st Division
2000 - 8th Premier league of 10 clubs
2001 - 5th
2002 - 4th
2003 - 2nd
2004 - 4th
2005 - 1st Champions
2006 - 2nd
2007 - 1st Champions
2008 - 1st Champions
2009 - 2nd
2010 - 1st Champions
2011 - 3rd
2012 - 3rd
2013 - 4th
2014 - 1st Champions
2015 - 4th
2016 - 2nd
2017 - 3rd
2018 - 2nd
2019 - 2nd
2020 - 3rd (Covid half season)
2021 - 6th
2022 - 2nd
2023 - 5th
2024 - 2nd