After the formation of the Surrey Cricketers' League 1st XI for the 1971 season a 2nd XI league was formed in readiness for the 1973 season. Reigate Priory was one of the 16 founder members and the history of the club's finishing positions in 2nd XI leagues since 1973 is detailed below.

1973 - 14th
1974 - 12th
1975 - 2nd
1976 - 3rd
1977 - 13th
1978 - 8th
1979 - 6th Extended to 17 clubs
1980 - 5th Extended to 18 clubs
1981 - 10th
1982 - 12th
1983 - 7th
1984 - 6th
1985 - 7th
1986 - 10th
1987 - 10th The league becomes the 2nd Div.of Surrey Championship
1988 - 4th
1989 - 9th
1990 - 9th
1991 - 2nd Promoted to the 22 club 1st Division
1992 - 19th
1993 - 12th
1994 - 20th
1995 - 16th
1996 - 11th
1997 - 11th
1998 - 10th
1999 - 3rd Top ten to form Premier Division for 2000
2000 - 8th Premier Division
2001 - 1st Champions
2002 - 2nd
2003 - 7th
2004 - 1st Champions
2005 - 1st Champions
2006 - 3rd
2007 - 5th
2008 - 5th
2009 - 3rd
2010 - 3rd
2011 - 3rd
2012 - 3rd
2013 - 4th
2014 - 1st Champions
2015 - 1st Champions
2016 - 2nd
2017 - 4th
2018 - 3rd
2019 - 5th
2020 -1st Champions (Covid half season)
2021 - 1st Champions
2022 - 4th
2023 - 9th Relegated
2024 - 3rd First Division